Some viewers have criticized “The Good Doctor” for its portrayal of autism, even labeling it as inaccurate and politically motivated. It’s important to address these concerns and understand why many find the show to be valuable and insightful.
Firstly, it’s crucial to recognize that autism is a spectrum. This means that autism affects each individual uniquely, resulting in a wide range of experiences and behaviors. Therefore, judging the representation of autism in “The Good Doctor,” or any single portrayal, as definitively “correct” or “incorrect” is inherently flawed. Shaun Murphy’s character showcases one possible experience within this spectrum, not a monolithic representation of all autistic individuals.
Secondly, accusations of political bias seem unfounded. “The Good Doctor” primarily focuses on medical cases and personal relationships within a hospital setting. The narrative doesn’t delve into political debates, controversial social issues, or explicitly leftist agendas. To inject political interpretations into the show appears to be a misreading of its core themes, which center around overcoming prejudice and demonstrating unique abilities.
Furthermore, criticisms regarding disabled characters being depicted as “superheroes” miss the positive message of the show. Highlighting the extraordinary capabilities of individuals with disabilities, like Shaun’s savant syndrome and exceptional memory, is not insulting. Instead, it can be seen as empowering and inspiring, much like recognizing the achievements of historical figures with disabilities such as Helen Keller or Stephen Hawking. “The Good Doctor” challenges preconceived notions and demonstrates that individuals with autism can be highly capable and contribute significantly to society.
“The Good Doctor” focuses on Dr. Shaun Murphy, a surgeon with autism and savant syndrome. Savant syndrome, often associated with autism, can manifest as exceptional skills in specific areas like memory or calculation, contrasting with potentially lower general IQ scores. Shaun’s remarkable memory and attention to detail become invaluable assets in his medical practice, enabling him to diagnose and treat patients effectively. While initial skepticism from colleagues is part of the dramatic narrative, Shaun consistently proves his abilities by saving lives and demonstrating his competence as a surgeon.
In essence, “The Good Doctor” offers a compelling medical drama while simultaneously presenting a nuanced, albeit fictionalized, portrayal of autism. It contributes to broader representation on television, moving away from stereotypical depictions and showcasing the potential and talent of individuals on the autism spectrum. The show encourages viewers to look beyond neurotypical norms and appreciate the diverse capabilities within the human experience.
