“Twice Upon a Time” serves as the poignant final chapter for Peter Capaldi’s tenure as the Twelfth Doctor, and in a masterstroke of storytelling, simultaneously revisits the very first incarnation of the Time Lord. This Christmas special is not just a regeneration story; it’s a thoughtful reflection on the Doctor’s journey, enhanced by the brilliant recreation of the First Doctor, originally portrayed by William Hartnell. The episode delicately balances nostalgia with forward momentum, offering a fitting tribute to both Capaldi’s era and the rich history of Doctor Who.
David Bradley steps into the shoes of the First Doctor, a role initially made iconic by William Hartnell, and delivers a performance that is both respectful and refreshing. Any initial concerns about the transition are swiftly dispelled as Bradley captures the mannerisms and essence of the original Doctor, injecting humor and charm into the character. His interaction with Peter Capaldi is a highlight, creating a dynamic that is both amusing and insightful. Capaldi himself is at the peak of his powers, delivering a nuanced and powerful performance as he grapples with his impending regeneration. The narrative crafted for his swan song is intelligent, emotionally resonant, and genuinely funny, hitting all the right notes for a celebratory yet melancholic farewell. Mark Gatiss adds another layer of intrigue as the Captain, whose role evolves into something surprisingly meaningful, enriching the overall narrative tapestry.
What elevates “Twice Upon a Time” further is its incorporation of the Great War, now widely recognized as World War I. The episode weaves in scenes set against this historical backdrop with remarkable sensitivity and beauty, prompting reflection on themes of time, memory, and the value of life. These segments are not merely decorative; they are integral to the story’s emotional core and philosophical depth, amplified by compelling performances from the entire cast. This narrative choice positions the episode as more than just science fiction; it becomes a poignant commentary on humanity and history.
In its pacing and character focus, “Twice Upon a Time” echoes the classic era of Doctor Who. It eschews relentless action in favor of character-driven drama, allowing the story to breathe and the emotional beats to resonate. This deliberate pacing is a strength, enabling the script, plot, and performances to truly shine. The episode prioritizes thoughtful storytelling over spectacle, reminiscent of the show’s earlier, more introspective episodes, which many long-time fans appreciate.
While the introduction of Jodie Whittaker’s Thirteenth Doctor at the regeneration’s climax is undeniably dramatic, some might find it slightly jarring. However, this brief moment should not overshadow the episode’s primary focus: Peter Capaldi’s magnificent departure as the Twelfth Doctor. He is given a send-off worthy of his exceptional portrayal, marked by renewed self-belief and resolution after a period of identity questioning throughout his regeneration cycle. This arc, masterfully handled by Steven Moffat, provides a satisfying sense of closure for Capaldi’s Doctor.
Addressing criticisms regarding the First Doctor’s portrayal as somewhat outdated in his attitudes, it is a minor point that, while present, does not significantly detract from the episode’s overall quality. These moments of comedic contrast, while perhaps unnecessary, are light-hearted and brief. They depict the First Doctor as a product of his time, a slightly patriarchal figure, which is arguably consistent with interpretations of the character across different eras of Doctor Who, including Richard Hurndall’s portrayal and even hints in William Hartnell’s original performances.
The return of Bill Potts, while a characteristic Steven Moffat trope of bringing back companions, is made palatable by Pearl Mackie’s strong performance and the beloved nature of her character. Although such recurring companion appearances might feel somewhat repetitive, Bill’s presence undeniably enhances the episode’s emotional depth and viewer enjoyment.
“Twice Upon a Time” masterfully blends nostalgia, emotion, and classic Doctor Who elements. The inclusion of the original Mondasian Cybermen and the seamless integration of the First Doctor’s recreation alongside the World War I backdrop create a unique and magical viewing experience. Coupled with a strong script and exceptional acting, this episode stands as a predominantly excellent piece of television and a truly fitting farewell to Peter Capaldi’s remarkable iteration of the Doctor.
Peter Capaldi’s contribution to Doctor Who has been immense, and Steven Moffat’s era, despite mixed opinions, has delivered several standout episodes, culminating in this memorable special.
Rating: 9/10
Series 10 Episode Ranking: High
