For many Doctor Who aficionados, “Midnight” stands out as not just a highlight of the revived series, but as a genuine contender for one of the greatest stories in the show’s extensive history. It’s a personal favorite amongst the “NuWho” era, and its brilliance lies in its ability to craft unbearable tension within the most confined of settings. Despite the beloved Donna Noble’s limited screen time and the episode’s near-exclusive location within a small transport vehicle, “Midnight” delivers a masterclass in suspense, echoing the masterful techniques of Alfred Hitchcock.
Russell T. Davies, the architect of Doctor Who’s successful revival, truly demonstrated his storytelling prowess with “Midnight”. He channeled Hitchcockian genius, creating a narrative that is simultaneously terrifying, gripping, and utterly suspenseful. This episode serves as a prime example of Davies’ exceptional ability to write stories of the highest caliber for the Doctor Who universe, showcasing why he is so celebrated by fans.
Beyond the ingenious story concept and the phenomenal script, “Midnight” is elevated by exceptional performances and direction. Alice Troughton rightfully earned accolades for her direction, executing the episode with precision and flair. David Tennant delivers a tour-de-force performance, solidifying his status not only as a phenomenal Doctor but as a truly outstanding television actor. His portrayal in “Midnight” is a benchmark of quality in TV drama.
Lesley Sharp, as the guest star, is equally mesmerizing, delivering a performance that is both utterly convincing and deeply chilling. The innovative use of repeated speech is a stroke of brilliance, made all the more impactful by Sharp’s unsettling and unforgettable execution. It’s a truly scary and remarkably impressive piece of acting that elevates the entire episode.
The supporting guest cast, including David Troughton, son of the Second Doctor Patrick Troughton, provides a robust and engaging presence, adding further depth to the narrative. The episode’s thematic resonance is also profound, drawing parallels to Hitchcock’s “Lifeboat” (itself inspired by Steinbeck’s work). “Midnight” expertly explores the dark side of human nature, examining how fear can drive individuals to turn against each other. This central theme taps into broader societal anxieties, making the story all the more relevant and impactful.
“Midnight” is, without question, Doctor Who at its absolute zenith. It is a true masterpiece of television, a testament to the power of compelling writing, exceptional acting, and masterful direction, all coming together to create something truly magical and unforgettable within the Doctor Who canon.
My Rating: 10/10.
