For devoted Whovians and casual viewers alike, ranking the Doctors is a cherished and often debated pastime. With Ncuti Gatwa’s fresh and dynamic portrayal of the Fifteenth Doctor captivating audiences in the latest series and the anticipation building for the 2024 Christmas special, now is the perfect moment to delve into a comprehensive ranking of all the Doctors. Inspired by Rotten Tomatoes’ critical and audience scores, we’re revisiting every regeneration to determine who truly embodied the spirit of the Time Lord. From the pioneering First Doctor to the latest incarnations, join us as we explore each Doctor’s era, performance, and overall impact on the beloved sci-fi series, informed by the insightful perspectives you find on Rotten Tomatoes.
19. Richard Hurndall (classic series, 20th Anniversary Special “The Five Doctors”)
Richard Hurndall in Doctor Who
Known for: Stepping into the shoes of “the original” Doctor. Highlight: A questionable allegiance, seemingly prepared to betray fellow incarnations for personal gain.
Richard Hurndall’s position at the bottom of this ranking is perhaps somewhat unfair, a sentiment echoed in some fan discussions on Rotten Tomatoes forums. His challenge was immense: to recreate William Hartnell’s iconic First Doctor for the 20th Anniversary special, “The Five Doctors.” Lacking complete access to Hartnell’s original performances due to missing BBC archives from the 1980s, Hurndall understandably leaned into the First Doctor’s more cantankerous aspects. The warmer, more compassionate facets of the original Doctor were largely absent, save for a few fleeting moments with Susan Foreman (Carole Ann Ford). While his portrayal served its purpose in 1983, the increased availability of Hartnell’s episodes and David Bradley’s later, more nuanced interpretation have diminished Hurndall’s standing. As Rotten Tomatoes user reviews often highlight, capturing the essence of a beloved character is a delicate balance, and in this instance, it fell slightly short.
18. David Bradley (An Adventure in Space and Time, New Series, “Twice Upon a Time” & “The Power of The Doctor”)
David Bradley in Doctor Who episode
Known for: A humorous disdain for modern technology, especially his successor’s sonic screwdriver. Highlight: His graceful acceptance of the regeneration cycle, paving the way for his twelfth (and thirteenth) selves.
David Bradley, much like Hurndall, faced the daunting task of portraying the First Doctor. However, Bradley benefited from his prior role as William Hartnell himself in An Adventure in Space and Time, a biographical drama about the genesis of Doctor Who. This unique preparation allowed Bradley to deliver a performance in “Twice Upon a Time” that resonated more closely with Hartnell’s original portrayal, while still incorporating his own distinctive touches. His First Doctor is depicted as frail and weary, befitting a Time Lord nearing the end of his initial life cycle. This fragility allowed the gentler aspects of the character to emerge, even as Steven Moffat’s script playfully addressed some of the perceived chauvinistic tendencies of the 1960s First Doctor. Bradley’s First Doctor, while well-received and a welcome return in “The Power of The Doctor,” ranks lower due to limited screen time and his status as not being a primary, numbered incarnation. Rotten Tomatoes audience reviews often praise Bradley’s portrayal for its authenticity and warmth, even in its brevity.
17. Peter Davison (classic series, seasons 19-21)
Peter Davison in Doctor Who (BBC)
Known for: Sporting a sprig of celery and a perpetually breathless demeanor. Highlight: Orchestrating the reunion of past selves to confront their former mentor in “The Five Doctors.”
Peter Davison, inheriting the role after Tom Baker’s iconic seven-year tenure, brought a charming and affable quality to the Fifth Doctor. Simultaneously juggling roles in All Creatures Great and Small and Sink or Swim, Davison’s era was marked by fluctuating writing quality and a production approach that sometimes leaned towards theatricality over compelling storytelling. While episodes like “The Arc of Infinity” and “The Five Doctors” showcased Davison’s vulnerable and thoughtful Doctor, inconsistent scripts and less-than-stellar production values often overshadowed his performance. As reflected in some Rotten Tomatoes critic reviews of classic Doctor Who seasons, the Fifth Doctor’s era is sometimes considered uneven, preventing Davison’s Doctor from consistently reaching his full potential.
16. Colin Baker (classic series, seasons 21-23)
Colin Baker in Doctor Who (BBC)
Known for: An infamously garish fashion sense and a booming voice he clearly enjoyed. Highlight: A moment of quiet devastation upon learning of Peri’s (Nicola Bryant) fate in “The Trial of a Time Lord,” orchestrated by Time Lord machinations.
Following the Fifth Doctor’s gentler nature, Colin Baker’s Sixth Doctor was conceived as a deliberate return to the Time Lord’s more abrasive, earlier persona. Emerging from a turbulent regeneration, this Doctor initially attempted to harm his companion and adopted a costume that remains a point of contention among fans. The intention, according to Baker, was for the Sixth Doctor to gradually mellow as he regained his humanity. However, audiences reacted negatively to this more unpleasant Doctor, and the BBC controversially placed the show on an 18-month hiatus. Upon its return with “The Trial of a Time Lord,” the narrative arc ultimately led to Colin Baker’s premature departure. While some retrospective Rotten Tomatoes audience scores appreciate the Sixth Doctor’s complexity, his era remains one of the most turbulent in Doctor Who history.
15. William Hartnell (classic series, seasons 1-4)
William Hartnell in Doctor Who (BBC)
Known for: Occasional line flubs and a quick temper. Highlight: His poignant farewell to his granddaughter, Susan, in “The Dalek Invasion of Earth,” a scene frequently cited as a series highlight in Rotten Tomatoes fan discussions.
Despite being the original, William Hartnell’s First Doctor occupies a unique position compared to his successors. Initially conceived as a foil to the show’s early companions, the First Doctor was often portrayed as irritable, self-centered, and even cold. As original companions departed and he evolved into the central protagonist, many of these sharper edges softened. The early seasons reveal his growing affection for Earth, yet the slower pacing and 1960s production values can make some of his stories less accessible to modern viewers. While Hartnell’s performance is often charming, it represents a significantly different iteration of Doctor Who. Rotten Tomatoes critic reviews from the time and retrospective analyses often acknowledge Hartnell’s foundational role while also noting the stylistic differences from later eras.
14. Jodie Whittaker (new series, seasons 11-13)
Jodie Whittaker in Doctor Who Series 11 Costume Reveal (BBC America)
Known for: Affectionately referring to her companions as her “fam.” Highlight: Her resourceful act of piecing together fragmented aspects of herself to overcome the Master’s manipulation within the Matrix on Gallifrey.
Jodie Whittaker’s Thirteenth Doctor followed Peter Capaldi’s more serious portrayal with a youthful energy and a rapid-fire delivery reminiscent of some of the more whimsical Doctors. However, overt clowning wasn’t her primary mode. This Doctor possessed a palpable passion and deep compassion, journeying alongside a consistent trio of companions, suggesting a heightened need for familial connection. This support system proved vital given the profound revelations about her past that unfolded during her tenure. Although the writing was often inconsistent, leading to a somewhat muddled character arc, Whittaker consistently imbued her Doctor with warmth and enthusiasm. Rotten Tomatoes audience reviews often praise Whittaker’s energy and warmth, even while acknowledging some criticisms of the writing during her era.
13. Ncuti Gatwa (Disney+ series, seasons 1-2)
Ncuti Gatwa in Doctor Who Preview
Known for: A striking array of costume changes. Highlight: The devastating realization in “Dot and Bubble” of his powerlessness to help due to ingrained prejudice.
Ncuti Gatwa’s Fifteenth Doctor debuted in an unconventional regeneration during the 60th-anniversary specials, succeeding David Tennant’s brief Fourteenth Doctor incarnation. He embodies a Dandy archetype, distinct from Jon Pertwee’s earlier portrayal, primarily through his ever-evolving fashion choices. Unlike Pertwee’s consistent style with color variations, Gatwa’s Doctor adapts his attire to the TARDIS’s destinations. Emotionally expressive, this Doctor frequently displays vulnerability, reflecting the ongoing processing of the Thirteenth Doctor’s past revelations, particularly the concept of being a Time Lord “orphan.” Driven by instinct as much as intellect, Gatwa’s Doctor navigates stories from returning showrunner Russell T. Davies, with varying critical reception as reflected on Rotten Tomatoes. The first season’s standout episode, “73 Yards,” ironically minimizes the Doctor’s direct involvement. With only a limited number of episodes aired, the long-term trajectory of Gatwa’s emotional and stylish Doctor remains to be seen, and future Rotten Tomatoes scores will undoubtedly shape his ultimate ranking.
12. Christopher Eccleston (new series, season 1)
Christopher Eccleston in Doctor Who (BBC America)
Known for: A brief but impactful tenure and the catchphrase “fantastic!” Highlight: His resolute declaration to rescue Rose Tyler (Billie Piper) and confront the Daleks in “The Parting of the Ways.”
Christopher Eccleston’s Ninth Doctor is marked by what might have been. A premature BBC announcement of his departure preceded the revived series’ debut. Initial US broadcast challenges further limited his visibility. The season itself was a blend of highs, exploring the Doctor’s PTSD, and lows, like the infamous farting aliens plotline. Eccleston’s Doctor was a whirlwind of manic energy, often hand-in-hand with Rose. His single season offered a glimpse of immense potential curtailed by production challenges that ultimately led to his departure, a sentiment often echoed in fan discussions on Rotten Tomatoes. Despite the brevity, Eccleston’s performance remains highly influential, and his return to the role in Big Finish audio dramas is celebrated by fans.
11. John Hurt (new series, 50th anniversary specials “The Day of The Doctor,” “The Time of The Doctor”)
John Hurt in Doctor Who (BBC America)
Known for: Bearing the weight of the Time War and wielding the sonic screwdriver with gravitas. Highlight: His palpable relief upon realizing he wouldn’t have to destroy Gallifrey in “The Day of The Doctor.”
Ranking the War Doctor, portrayed by John Hurt, is inherently challenging due to his limited appearances in the 50th-anniversary specials. Yet, Hurt’s brief portrayal is undeniably powerful. Initially conceived as a retcon where Eccleston’s Doctor was intended to be the Gallifrey destroyer, Hurt emerged as a secret regeneration, embodying the Doctor at his darkest point. Drawing from Hartnell’s grittiness and Davison’s vulnerability, he became an avatar of classic Doctors within the anniversary celebration. Rotten Tomatoes critic and audience scores for “The Day of the Doctor” are overwhelmingly positive, reflecting the impact of Hurt’s performance in such a pivotal story.
10. Jo Martin (new series, season 12 episodes “The Fugitive of the Judoon,” “The Timeless Children”)
Jo Martin in Doctor Who season 12
Known for: Surprise appearances and shattering established Doctor Who lore. Highlight: Her assertive declaration to the Thirteenth Doctor (Whittaker) that her favorite part of any encounter is stating, “I am The Doctor.”
Jo Martin’s Fugitive Doctor was a complete surprise, revealed as a previously unknown incarnation from the Doctor’s forgotten past. Beneath the guise of Ruth Clayton, a kind tour guide, Martin’s Doctor exuded a confident swagger, often perceived as bravado in other incarnations, but here, it enhanced a remarkably resolute version of the character. The concepts of “Time’s Champion” and “Time Lord Triumphant” gain new resonance when considering her potential influence across the Doctor’s timeline. Despite limited screen time, the Fugitive Doctor made a significant impression, leaving viewers eager for more exploration of this mysterious incarnation. Rotten Tomatoes user reviews from season 12 frequently highlight Martin’s impactful performance and the intriguing questions her character raised.
9. David Tennant (The 60th Anniversary Specials)
Known for: A striking resemblance to a previous Doctor. Highlight: Reconnecting with former companion Melanie Bush (Bonnie Langford) and later at a Noble family gathering, bridging past and present.
As the Fourteenth Doctor, a distinct regeneration (unlike the “10.5” Doctor), David Tennant earns his place, albeit lower due to his brief three-special tenure. Reconstituted into a familiar form for yet-to-be-fully-explained reasons, the Fourteenth Doctor mirrors the Tenth, yet with subtle nuances. He openly expresses love, a trait the Tenth Doctors struggled with. He embodies a Doctor in retreat, grappling with past traumas and using his “allons-y” catchphrase as a deflection. However, he is on a path to recovery, currently residing with Donna Noble while his successor adventures. The possibility of Tennant’s return remains open, a prospect eagerly anticipated by many fans. Rotten Tomatoes audience scores for the 60th-anniversary specials reflect the strong positive reception to Tennant’s return and portrayal of the Fourteenth Doctor.
8. Sylvester McCoy (classic series, seasons 24-26)
Sylvester McCoy in Doctor Who (BBC)
Known for: Spoon playing and a distinctive Panama hat. Highlight: His composed offer of self-destruction to the Daleks in “Remembrance of the Daleks,” their final classic series appearance.
Sylvester McCoy’s Seventh Doctor initially presented as a whimsical clown, undergoing a dramatic transformation into a master manipulator by the classic series’ end. Alternating between warmth and calculated manipulation, the Seventh Doctor prioritized long-term goals, even at the expense of allies. McCoy mirrored this shift with a darker costume and a deeper vocal tone, hinting at a more ancient and alien Doctor. These intriguing concepts were unfortunately cut short by the series’ hiatus. Retrospective Rotten Tomatoes reviews of the classic series often praise McCoy’s later seasons and the Seventh Doctor’s complexity.
7. Paul McGann (the TV movie)
Paul McGann in Doctor Who (BBC)
Known for: Romantic inclinations and a debated half-human heritage. Highlight: His poignant remembrance of past companions in “The Night of The Doctor.”
Paul McGann’s brief TV movie appearance as the Eighth Doctor sparked a lasting legacy and numerous “what ifs.” Intended to relaunch Doctor Who for American audiences in 1996, McGann’s Doctor was consciously designed with romantic appeal, a dimension he portrayed brilliantly. While the TV movie itself is often critically panned, McGann’s performance shone, suggesting an engaging, intelligent, and vulnerable Doctor. McGann expanded the Eighth Doctor’s story through audio dramas, culminating in his celebrated return in the mini-episode “The Night of The Doctor.” Rotten Tomatoes audience scores for McGann’s audio work and “Night of the Doctor” are overwhelmingly positive, highlighting his enduring popularity.
6. David Tennant (new series, Season 2-4)
David Tennant in Doctor Who (BBC America)
Known for: Romantic relationships, and the iconic phrase “wibbley-wobbly, timey-wimey.” Highlight: His fierce determination in “The Family of Blood,” punishing those who forced his Time Lord return.
The most popular of the new series Doctors, David Tennant’s Tenth Doctor benefited from exceptional scripts and storytelling. From “School Reunion” to “Blink” and the emotional climax of “Journey’s End,” the Tenth Doctor explored previously unseen depths of the Doctor’s psyche, notably a deep-seated fear of regeneration and losing his “Tennant-ness.” He amplified the romantic potential glimpsed with McGann and embodied a weariness inherited from Eccleston, becoming “the man who regrets.” His era remains a high point for many fans, a sentiment reflected in consistently high Rotten Tomatoes audience scores for seasons 2-4.
5. Jon Pertwee (classic series, seasons 7-11)
Jon Pertwee in Doctor Who (BBC)
Known for: Velvet jackets and a penchant for gadgets. Highlight: Sharing a childhood story to comfort a companion in “The Time Monster,” revealing a more personal side.
Jon Pertwee’s Third Doctor was theatrical, dandyish, yet more grounded than many other incarnations. Pertwee shed his variety entertainer persona to play the Doctor as a patrician hero. Exiled to Earth and working with UNIT, he formed a family, valuing truth and righteousness. Simultaneously, he indulged in gadgetry and special vehicles, mirroring Pertwee’s own personality. Rotten Tomatoes retrospective critic reviews often highlight Pertwee’s era as a stylish and action-packed chapter in Doctor Who history.
4. Peter Capaldi (new series, seasons 8-10)
Peter Capaldi in Doctor Who (BBC America)
Known for: Scottish accent and a commanding “Shut up!” Highlight: His defining statement in “Death in Heaven”: “I’m an idiot in a box, passing through, helping out, learning.”
Peter Capaldi’s Twelfth Doctor presented an imposing figure, fulfilling the long-awaited return to a more Hartnell-esque regeneration. Often as acerbic as the First and as self-absorbed as the Sixth, Capaldi also embodied the dream casting of a lifelong Doctor Who fan and Oscar-winning actor taking command of the TARDIS. Despite some uneven storylines, Capaldi’s performance consistently delivered a delightful unpredictability and a hint of menace, reminiscent of the early Doctors. Rotten Tomatoes critic reviews often lauded Capaldi’s performance as a highlight, even when storylines received mixed reception.
3. Matt Smith (new series, seasons 5-7)
Matt Smith in Doctor Who (BBC America)
Known for: Bow ties and unwavering loyalty to friends. Highlight: Providing Vincent Van Gogh with a moment of solace and recognition in “Vincent and The Doctor.”
Matt Smith, surprisingly, grew up unfamiliar with Doctor Who. Yet, he swiftly grasped the character’s quirky charm and ancient gravitas. Modeling his Doctor on an eccentric professor, Smith’s rapid speech and energetic gestures contributed to the series’ peak popularity in the US. Both youthful and ancient, Smith’s Doctor could evoke laughter and heartbreak in rapid succession. Rotten Tomatoes audience scores during Smith’s era reflect the broad appeal and critical success of his portrayal.
2. Tom Baker (classic series, seasons 12-18)
Tom Baker in Doctor Who (BBC)
Known for: The iconic long scarf and Jelly Babies. Highlight: His humorous “Cockneys!” exclamation in “The Talons of Weng-Chaing,” showcasing his eccentric humor.
Tom Baker was arguably born to play the Doctor, and as he often claims, never truly stopped. Infusing the Doctor with his alien mannerisms and vocal quirks, he became the definitive Doctor for decades. Even in weaker stories, Baker’s commitment to a seemingly whimsical yet deeply caring hero never wavered. He also benefited from the consistent presence of writer Robert Holmes. Tom Baker’s era consistently receives high Rotten Tomatoes audience scores and is considered a golden age for many fans.
1. Patrick Troughton (classic series, seasons 4-6)
Patrick Troughton in Doctor Who (BBC)
Known for: Urging companions to run and his signature trouser-checking gesture. Highlight: Reassuring Victoria in “The Tomb of the Cybermen” with the profound statement, “no one else in the universe can do what we do.”
With the exception of Hartnell, every Doctor owes a debt to Patrick Troughton. Facing the pressure of replacing the original Doctor, he established much of the character’s core persona. His indignant retorts, playful retreats, and grave warnings resonate through subsequent Doctors. The Second Doctor embodies the meddling Time Lord driven by curiosity and a desire to help. Unlike some successors, Troughton’s Doctor openly displayed vulnerability, revealing moments of being out of his depth, yet always recovering his confidence. His performance, marked by a slight vocal rasp and a twinkle in his eye, made him the quintessential Doctor. Rotten Tomatoes fan polls and retrospective rankings often place Troughton at or near the top, recognizing his foundational contribution to the Doctor Who legacy.
Who do you think is the best Doctor? Let us know in the comments!
Don’t miss the 2024 Doctor Who Christmas Special, “Joy to the World”, streaming on Disney+ this December 25th!
Follow Rotten Tomatoes for more Doctor Who updates on social media.
