For fans of the long-running series Doctor Who, each regeneration of the Doctor brings a mix of anticipation and apprehension. Stepping into the shoes of a beloved predecessor is no small feat, and Peter Davison faced precisely this challenge when he took on the mantle of the Fifth Doctor. Following the iconic and lengthy tenure of Tom Baker’s Fourth Doctor, Davison’s arrival marked a significant shift in tone and style. This article explores the era of the Fifth Doctor, examining his personality, companions, key storylines, and lasting impact on the Doctor Who universe.
Fifth Doctor 9
A Doctor of Youth and Vulnerability
Peter Davison’s Fifth Doctor debuted in 1982, ushering in Seasons 19 through 21 of classic Doctor Who. Born in the same year Season 19 began, the author of the original article approached this era with a sense of nervous excitement, a feeling relatable to many fans starting a new Doctor’s journey. This initial hesitation mirrors the very essence of the Fifth Doctor’s early portrayal – one of vulnerability and uncertainty.
The regeneration itself in “Castrovalva: Part One” is portrayed as particularly turbulent. In a symbolic gesture, the Fifth Doctor literally unravels the Fourth Doctor’s iconic scarf, shedding the remnants of his past persona. This visual cue, further emphasized by discarding shoes, coat, and even tearing his vest, boldly declares a departure. The bohemian, whimsical Fourth Doctor is gone, replaced by someone noticeably different.
The Fifth Doctor’s appearance immediately sets him apart. Trading the bohemian look for a more “preppy” style – sneakers, slacks, a pullover sweater – Davison’s Doctor presents a youthful, almost boyish figure. This visual change is more than just costume; it reflects a deeper shift in the Doctor’s character. While still brilliant and resourceful, the Fifth Doctor is often depicted as more unsure and reactive than some of his previous incarnations. This Doctor is learning on the job, grappling with the weight of responsibility, and often displaying a charming, slightly awkward demeanor.
Interestingly, this era also marked a subtle change in the show’s credits. Davison was credited as “The Doctor,” not “Doctor Who,” a small detail highlighting this regeneration’s distinct identity within the larger Doctor Who narrative.
Fifth Doctor
The TARDIS Family Dynamic: Companions of the Fifth Doctor
The Fifth Doctor inherited a TARDIS already populated with companions: Adric, Nyssa, and Tegan Jovanka. This pre-existing dynamic allowed for immediate exploration of group interactions, setting the stage for what many consider a “family” atmosphere within the TARDIS. The original article aptly describes this era as having an “80s sitcom premise,” with the Fifth Doctor as a young, single parent figure navigating the complexities of his unconventional family.
-
Tegan Jovanka: The outspoken and often exasperated Australian air hostess, Tegan provides a grounded, sarcastic perspective. Her quick wit and no-nonsense attitude often clash with the Doctor’s alien logic, creating humorous and relatable moments. Tegan embodies the role of the “sassy older daughter,” unafraid to voice her opinions and frustrations.
-
Nyssa of Traken: In contrast to Tegan’s fiery personality, Nyssa is calm, intelligent, and empathetic. Her Trakenite heritage grants her a unique perspective and a natural inclination towards harmony. Nyssa often acts as a mediator between the Doctor and Tegan, striving to maintain peace within the TARDIS crew. She represents the “harmonious middle daughter,” seeking balance and understanding.
-
Adric: The young Alzarian mathematical genius, Adric, is eager to prove himself and often seeks the Doctor’s approval. His youth and inexperience sometimes lead to insecurity and rash decisions, but his intelligence and loyalty are undeniable. Adric is portrayed as the “youngest brother,” yearning for recognition and struggling with teenage angst.
Later in the Fifth Doctor’s era, Turlough joined the TARDIS crew. Initially presented as untrustworthy and under the influence of the Black Guardian, Turlough’s character arc evolves throughout his time with the Doctor. His cynical nature and self-serving tendencies provide a contrasting viewpoint within the group dynamic. Finally, Peri Brown, an American botany student, becomes the Fifth Doctor’s last companion. Peri brings a fresh, inquisitive energy and a more contemporary Earth perspective to the TARDIS.
Fifth Doctor 11 (2)
Fifth Doctor 12
Fifth Doctor 13
The Fifth Doctor’s paternal energy is a defining characteristic of his era. This is reminiscent of the First Doctor’s travels with his granddaughter Susan and later Vicki, but the Fifth Doctor’s interactions carry a distinct warmth and overt affection for his companions. He is seen simultaneously guiding, reprimanding, and praising them, showcasing a deep care for their well-being and development. This dynamic resonated deeply with viewers, adding an emotional core to the Fifth Doctor’s adventures.
Villains and Storylines: Exploring Themes of Colonization and Morality
The Fifth Doctor’s era presented a mix of classic Doctor Who villains and new adversaries, often exploring complex themes.
-
Returning Villains: The Cybermen, Omega, the Mara, the Black Guardian, the Master, and the Daleks all made appearances during this time. These familiar foes provided a sense of continuity while being reinterpreted within the Fifth Doctor’s more vulnerable and emotionally driven narrative.
-
The Terileptils: A visually striking new alien race introduced in “The Visitation,” the Terileptils are reptilian humanoids who seek to colonize Earth after escaping a life sentence. Their story delves into themes of colonization, imperialism, and environmental stewardship, issues that recur throughout the Fifth Doctor’s era.
-
The Mara: A psychic entity that preys on negative emotions and nightmares, the Mara features in two serials, “Kinda” and “Snakedance.” Inspired by Buddhist and Hindu concepts, the Mara stories explore themes of delusion, suffering, and the power of inner reflection. The Kinda, a matriarchal society, and their connection to Sanskrit terms like “Jnana,” further enrich these thematic explorations.
Fifth Doctor 7
Fifth Doctor 8
A notable aspect of the Fifth Doctor’s stories is the reduced reliance on the sonic screwdriver. In contrast to modern Doctor Who, the Fifth Doctor uses his sonic screwdriver sparingly, emphasizing his intellect and resourcefulness as his primary tools. This harkens back to the earlier days of Doctor Who, where the Doctor relied more on his wit and ingenuity than technological gadgets.
Furthermore, the companions in this era are depicted as increasingly capable. Nyssa becomes adept at piloting the TARDIS and constructing complex devices, while Tegan learns to operate the TARDIS console. Even Adric frequently takes the helm of the TARDIS. This empowerment of the companions showcases their growth and contribution to the Doctor’s adventures, moving beyond simply being rescued to actively participating in problem-solving.
A Shift Towards Darkness and Moral Ambiguity
While the Fifth Doctor’s era often carried a lighter, almost sitcom-like tone in its early seasons, it gradually transitioned towards darker and more morally complex storylines. This shift is most evident in the latter part of his tenure.
-
Adric’s Death: The death of Adric in “Earthshock” is a watershed moment in Doctor Who history. As the first companion to die (in the classic series), Adric’s sacrifice to prevent a Cyberman ship from crashing into Earth 65 million years ago – causing the extinction of the dinosaurs – is a tragic and impactful event. The silent credits rolling over Adric’s broken star badge underscore the gravity of this loss, a stark departure from the usual Doctor Who narrative.
-
Moral Dilemmas: Following Adric’s death, the Fifth Doctor faces increasingly challenging moral choices. In “Resurrection of the Daleks,” he contemplates killing Davros to prevent the Daleks’ resurgence. He goes as far as arming himself to murder Davros and shows a ruthless side when dealing with Daleks in the field. Similarly, in “Planet of Fire,” the Doctor witnesses the Master’s apparent death by fire and chooses not to intervene, a shocking display of inaction that highlights the moral gray areas explored during this era.
Fifth Doctor 20
Fifth Doctor 21
FIfth Doctor 15
This descent into darkness and moral ambiguity may reflect the changing cultural landscape of the 1980s. The rise of action heroes and grittier narratives in film and television may have influenced Doctor Who‘s direction, pushing the series to explore more complex and challenging themes. The Fifth Doctor’s era, in this sense, foreshadows the darker tones and moral complexities that would become more prominent in modern Doctor Who.
Legacy and Influence of the Fifth Doctor
Despite the initial hesitation some fans might have felt after Tom Baker’s departure, Peter Davison’s Fifth Doctor quickly won over audiences with his warmth, empathy, and vulnerability. His portrayal of the Doctor as a more human, relatable figure resonated with viewers and left a lasting impact on the series.
The original article notes parallels between the Fifth Doctor and David Tennant’s Tenth Doctor. Similarities in mannerisms, physicality, and the ability to shift between lightheartedness and seriousness suggest a clear influence. The Fifth Doctor’s struggle with regeneration amnesia also foreshadows similar storylines in later iterations of the Doctor, including Jodie Whittaker’s Thirteenth Doctor.
Ultimately, the Fifth Doctor’s era is remembered for its strong character dynamics, exploration of complex themes, and its willingness to push the boundaries of Doctor Who storytelling. It bridged the gap between the whimsical adventures of the Fourth Doctor and the darker, more introspective direction the series would eventually take. For those exploring classic Doctor Who, the Fifth Doctor’s era is a crucial and rewarding chapter, offering a unique and compelling take on the Time Lord.
Fifth Doctor 6
The Brigadier’s final appearance in the Fifth Doctor’s era was a nostalgic moment for long-time fans.
A humorous promotional image featuring Jon Pertwee and the wax dummy of Tom Baker’s Fourth Doctor for “The Five Doctors.”
Fifth Doctor 26
The Fifth Doctor’s expressive face often conveyed his endearing and sometimes overwhelmed nature.
The Fifth Doctor’s “cute” and youthful appearance contributed to his unique charm.
The Fifth Doctor’s darker moments, like contemplating killing Davros, marked a shift in tone for the series.
The Master’s gruesome demise in “Planet of Fire” showcased the increasing darkness of the Fifth Doctor era.
The Doctor, Tegan, and Turlough at the TARDIS console, embodying the enduring appeal of the Fifth Doctor’s TARDIS family.
Further Explorations of the Doctor’s Regenerations:
- Impressions of the First Doctor
- Impressions of the Second Doctor
- Impressions of the Third Doctor
- Impressions of the Fourth Doctor
References:
[1] Peter Grimwade, dir. “Earthshock: Part Three,” Doctor Who, season 19, episode 21, BBC, 1982.
[2] Peter Moffatt, dir. “The Visitation: Part Four,” Doctor Who, season 19, episode 16, BBC, 1982.
[3] Mary Ridge, dir. “Terminus: Part Four,” Doctor Who, season 20, episode 16, BBC, 1983.
[4] Peter Grimwade, dir. “Earthshock: Part One,” Doctor Who, season 19, episode 19, BBC, 1982.
[5] Ron Jones, dir. “Black Orchid: Part One,” Doctor Who, season 19, episode 17, BBC, 1982.
[6] Fiona Cumming, dir. “Castrovalva: Part Three,” Doctor Who, season 19, episode 3, BBC, 1982.
[7] Peter Moffatt, dir. “The Visitation: Part Three,” Doctor Who, season 19, episode 15, BBC, 1982.
[8] Ibid.
[9] Fiona Cumming, dir. “Castrovalva: Part Two,” Doctor Who, season 19, episode 2, BBC, 1982.
[10] Peter Moffatt, dir. “Mawdryn Undead: Part One” Doctor Who, season 20, episode 9, BBC, 1983.
[11] Peter Moffatt, dir. “Mawdryn Undead,” Doctor Who, season 20, serial 3, BBC, 1983.
[12] Jamie Donoughue, dir. “The Legend of Ruby Sunday,” season 1, episode 8, BBC and Disney+, 2024.
[13] Peter Grimwade, dir. “Kinda: Part One,’ Doctor Who, season 19, episode 9, BBC, 1982.
[14] Peter Grimwade, dir. “Kinda: Part Three,” Doctor Who, season 20, episode 11, BBC, 1982.
[15] Peter Grimwade, dir. “Kinda: Part Two,” Doctor Who, season 19, episode 10, BBC, 1982.
[16] Peter Grimwade, dir. “Kinda: Part Three,” Doctor Who, season 20, episode 11, BBC, 1982.
[17] Peter Grimwade, dir. “Kinda: Part Four,” Doctor Who, season 19, episode 12, BBC, 1982.
[18] Peter Grimwade, dir. “Earthshock,” Doctor Who, season 19, serial 6, BBC, 1982.
[19] Ron Jones, dir. “Arc of Infinity,” Doctor Who, season 20, serial 1, BBC, 1983.
[20] Fiona Cumming, dir. “Snakedance,” Doctor Who, season 20, serial 2, BBC, 1983.
[21] Fiona Cumming, dir. “Enlightenment,” Doctor Who, season 20, serial 5, BBC, 1983.
[22] Just, like, ALL THE TIME.
[23] Matthew Robinson, dir. “Resurrection of the Daleks,” Doctor Who, season 21, serial 4, BBC, 1984.
[24] Well, technically Katarina, who sacrificed herself to save the First Doctor and Steven in 1966’s “The Daleks’ Master Plan,” was but she was just with them for an episode and all her serials are lost.
[25] Peter Grimwade, dir. “Earthshock: Part Four” Doctor Who, season 19, episode 22, BBC, 1982.
[26] Ron Jones, dir. “Time-Flight,” Doctor Who, season 19, episode 23, BBC, 1982.
[27] Matthew Robinson, dir. “Resurrection of the Daleks: Part Two” Doctor Who, season 21, episode 12, BBC, 1984.
[28] Matthew Robinson, dir. “Resurrection of the Daleks: Part One” Doctor Who, season 21, episode 11, BBC, 1984.
[29] Matthew Robinson, dir. “Resurrection of the Daleks: Part Two” Doctor Who, season 21, episode 12, BBC, 1984.
[30] Fiona Cumming, dir. “Planet of Fire: Part Four,” Doctor Who, season 21, episode 16, BBC, 1984.
[31] Mary Ridge, dir. “Terminus: Part Four,” Doctor Who, season 20, episode 16, BBC, 1983
[32] Matthew Robinson, dir. “Resurrection of the Daleks: Part Two” Doctor Who, season 21, episode 12, BBC, 1984.
[33] Fiona Cumming, dir. “Planet of Fire: Part Four,” Doctor Who, season 21, episode 16, BBC, 1984.
[34] Ron Jones, dir. “Black Orchid: Part One,” Doctor Who, season 19, episode 17, BBC, 1982.
