Navigating the world of mattresses can be a confusing and, at times, frustrating experience. Like many, the search for a comfortable and supportive bed led me down a path of trying various options, including the Denver Mattress Doctor’s Choice Plush. My journey, filled with unexpected twists and turns, ultimately highlighted the critical factors to consider when choosing a mattress, and why the seemingly ideal choice might not always be the perfect fit.
My initial foray into mattress buying involved the Denver Mattress Doctor’s Choice Plush. Intrigued by its reputation and the promise of plush comfort, I opted for this model. For the first two years, it seemed like a decent choice. However, I soon encountered the dreaded issue of sagging – a problem that plagues many mattresses and disrupts restful sleep. Interestingly, this experience contrasted sharply with the firm version of the same mattress. While the plush model started sagging after just over two years, the firm version, which I also tried, exhibited sagging in less than seven months. This unexpected reversal of typical mattress performance raised questions about consistency and long-term durability.
Driven by the need for a more reliable and supportive sleep surface, I began exploring alternative mattress types, with latex emerging as a promising option. The search led me to local mattress manufacturers and retailers specializing in latex beds, a stark contrast to the mainstream furniture stores that often prioritize polyfoam and memory foam constructions.
One of my first stops was Sanitary Mattress, where I had a truly informative and personalized experience. The owner, a knowledgeable craftsman, demonstrated the mattress-making process and patiently listened to my concerns. Explaining my previous issues with sagging and discomfort, we discussed the potential benefits of latex. I spent a considerable amount of time testing their latex mattress, which, despite feeling firmer than initially desired, didn’t trigger the shoulder and hip pain I typically experience with firm innerspring mattresses. This particular mattress was a tri-zoned, two-sided flippable design made with natural Talalay latex, although not entirely 100% natural due to the manufacturing process involving a small amount of soap. While not a purist in terms of organic materials, the concept of a latex blend with balanced aging properties intrigued me.
However, a significant drawback emerged: the cotton cover was quilted with an inch of polyfoam. This revelation was disheartening. The quest for a durable and sag-resistant mattress seemed constantly thwarted by the ubiquitous presence of polyfoam, a material known for its tendency to break down over time and contribute to sagging. It felt like escaping polyfoam in mattresses was an almost impossible mission. The owner offered a non-quilted cover option, but it felt and looked like plastic, raising concerns about comfort and breathability. He also suggested replacing the polyfoam quilting with a 1-inch 20 ILD latex topper, but wasn’t certain about how it would affect the stitching or overall feel. Despite these uncertainties, the mattress itself, priced at $1400 with a foundation, and backed by a 15-year warranty, held appeal. The warranty, evaluated on a case-by-case basis without a specific sag threshold, indicated a confidence in the product’s quality, although the lack of a defined threshold also introduced a degree of uncertainty.
The experience at Sanitary Mattress was positive overall, marked by honest advice and a lack of sales pressure. The owner’s willingness to admit when he didn’t know something and his offer of free delivery further solidified a sense of trust. The hesitations, however, remained centered on the polyfoam quilting and the perceived firmness. The question lingered: could the polyfoam be replaced with a more durable material like cotton or polyester for a reasonable price?
Continuing my search, I visited Tri-City Furniture, a store with a vast inventory that bordered on overwhelming. They carried Pure Latex Bliss (PLB) mattresses, offering three models. The least expensive model felt excessively firm, causing shoulder pressure within minutes. The second model was surprisingly soft, almost too soft, despite being described as firmer than the top-tier option. The most expensive, a 13-inch model, felt the most balanced – neither too firm nor too soft, and comfortable during a 15-minute test.
A notable feature of the PLB mattresses was their zippered covers, designed for washing, though the latex cores appeared to be solid and non-adjustable. The covers themselves had minimal quilting and, in most models, included an “advanced gel-infused temperature regulating” top layer, indicated by a blue rectangle. Upon inspecting the cover, it was evident that there was no polyfoam, a welcome discovery. However, all PLB mattresses were single-sided, limiting the option to flip and extend their lifespan.
Unfortunately, the salesman lacked in-depth knowledge about the product, unable to provide ILD ratings or understand basic mattress terminology. Despite his lack of expertise, he was amiable and offered discounts on accessories. The major drawback with PLB mattresses was the price. The best-feeling model was a staggering $3500, and even the entry-level option was around $2000, potentially requiring an additional $550 topper to achieve the desired plushness. The high price point made PLB mattresses less competitive compared to other latex options like EZ Sleep and Habitat, which offer more flexibility and affordability.
This mattress shopping journey led to a crucial realization: latex mattresses offer a promising alternative to conventional innerspring and foam beds, particularly for those seeking durability and pressure relief. While the Denver Mattress Doctor’s Choice Plush initially seemed appealing, its sagging issues highlighted the importance of considering material quality and construction. The exploration of latex options, though still presenting challenges in terms of polyfoam components and firmness levels, revealed the potential for a more lasting and comfortable sleep solution. The ideal mattress, it became clear, requires careful consideration of materials, construction, and personal comfort preferences, extending beyond initial impressions and brand reputation.
