The Good Doctor has captivated audiences for seven seasons with its compelling medical cases and deeply human characters. Among them, Dr. Asher Wolke, portrayed by Noah Galvin, stood out with his unique journey of self-discovery and acceptance. While his sudden departure in season 7 left viewers in shock, understanding the narrative purpose behind Asher’s death provides a deeper appreciation for his character arc and the show’s willingness to tackle real-world issues.
Asher’s Journey: From Hasidic Jew to Self-Accepting Doctor
Dr. Asher Wolke’s introduction in season 4 brought a fresh perspective to St. Bonaventure Hospital. As a former Hasidic Jew who left his community at 18 and embraced atheism, Asher grappled with his identity throughout his time on the show. His personal life took a significant turn when he began a relationship with Jerome Martel, highlighting his open and proud gay identity. However, season 7 marked a pivotal point in Asher’s journey as he started to reconnect with his Jewish roots. Inspired by a rabbi who showed him that his faith and sexual orientation could coexist, Asher began to reconcile his past and present. This exploration of his identity was further fueled by his parents’ wish to see him married, prompting him to consider his future with Jerome and his place within his heritage. This journey of self-acceptance makes his sudden and tragic end even more impactful.
A Hate-Fueled Crime: The Circumstances of Asher’s Death
In a shocking turn of events in season 7, episode 5, “Who At Peace,” Asher’s journey was abruptly cut short. After discovering two men vandalizing his synagogue, Asher bravely intervened, even after being threatened. Tragically, this act of courage led to a fatal hate crime. Asher was ambushed and murdered, struck down while defending a sacred space he had only recently begun to embrace again. The heartbreaking scene of his death, juxtaposed with Jerome waiting for him at a restaurant for their date, underscored the sudden and senseless nature of the violence. This event resonated deeply with viewers, prompting discussions about hate crimes and their devastating impact.
The Writer’s Rationale: Heroism and Harsh Realities
The suddenness of Asher’s death sparked debate among fans, with some questioning the narrative choice. However, The Good Doctor writer Adam Scott Weissman offered insight into the decision, emphasizing the show’s intent to reflect the harsh realities of life. According to Weissman, Asher’s death was designed to be a poignant reminder that “life doesn’t always have happy endings.” He explained to TheWrap that such tragedies often become impactful when they affect beloved characters, bringing real-world issues to the forefront for viewers.
Weissman further framed Asher’s death as “heroic,” highlighting that it occurred as he was embracing all facets of his identity to protect a sacred space and others. This perspective emphasizes Asher’s growth and courage in his final moments. Despite the tragedy, his death is portrayed as a powerful statement about standing up for one’s beliefs and defending against hate, even in the face of danger.
Navigating the “Bury Your Gays” Trope
The death of a gay character in such a violent manner naturally raised concerns about the “Bury Your Gays” trope, a problematic pattern in media where LGBTQ+ characters are disproportionately killed off, often for shock value or to elicit tragedy. Weissman acknowledged awareness of this trope within the writing team. While acknowledging the potential for such interpretations, he argued that Asher’s death, while tragic, served a different purpose. It wasn’t simply tragedy for tragedy’s sake, but rather a commentary on real-world hate crimes and a moment for Asher to heroically defend a part of himself he had long denied. This nuance distinguishes Asher’s storyline from more blatant and insensitive examples of the “Bury Your Gays” trope, offering a more complex and socially relevant narrative.
Conclusion: A Lasting Impact
Asher Wolke’s death on The Good Doctor was undoubtedly a heartbreaking moment for viewers. However, examining the narrative choices reveals a deeper intention beyond mere shock value. Asher’s journey of self-discovery, culminating in a heroic act against hate, provides a powerful and poignant storyline. His death serves as a stark reminder of the real-world dangers of hate crimes and the importance of embracing one’s identity, even when faced with adversity. While his absence is deeply felt, Asher’s story leaves a lasting impact, prompting reflection on identity, courage, and the fight against prejudice within the context of a beloved medical drama.
