The question of whether Jenna Louise Coleman would remain in Doctor Who loomed large over season 8, fueling constant speculation. Whispers of her departure circulated widely, amplified by the BBC’s deliberate ambiguity, neither confirming nor denying the rumors. This coyness only heightened fan intrigue, leaving everyone guessing about the fate of Clara Oswald. It was understandable why Coleman might consider moving on. Her initial run alongside Matt Smith’s Eleventh Doctor, while charming, often relegated Clara to the enigma of “the impossible girl,” sometimes overshadowing her character’s depth despite Coleman’s captivating performance. Just as their Doctor-companion dynamic began to flourish, Smith regenerated, ushering in Peter Capaldi’s radically different Twelfth Doctor. Coleman then navigated a new dynamic, guiding Capaldi’s Doctor—an older, more alien, and decidedly irascible incarnation reminiscent of William Hartnell’s era—through his early episodes.
doctor-who-death-in-heaven-review-clara
Season 8 took an unexpected turn, shifting the narrative focus in a way that surprised some viewers. The Doctor, to the dismay of some traditionalists, occasionally became a supporting player in Clara’s increasingly complex life. Critics even playfully dubbed the season “Clara Who,” highlighting this shift. An episode in the latter half of the season even featured Clara impersonating the Doctor, initially for comedic effect, before confronting the more serious implication that her time with the Doctor was blurring her own identity. Regardless of audience opinions on this companion-centric approach, it undeniably provided Jenna Louise Coleman with rich and compelling material. This led many to wonder: with such substantial storylines, why would Jenna Louise Coleman even contemplate leaving Doctor Who?
As it turned out, Jenna Louise Coleman reached the same conclusion. Clara Oswald not only survived season 8 but also navigated a season finale and Christmas special that felt deliberately crafted to facilitate her departure, should she have chosen to take it. In “Death in Heaven,” Clara and the Doctor shared a poignant, amicable farewell, albeit built on mutual falsehoods. Clara claimed her deceased fiancé, Danny Pink, had returned (a complicated lie involving Cybermen and the afterlife), while the Doctor falsely declared he had found Gallifrey. The Doctor’s influence had profoundly impacted Clara’s life, and her parting act was to absolve him, masking the true extent of her personal cost with a comforting lie. It was a bittersweet, ambiguous conclusion.
Screen-Shot-2014-12-27-at-11.11.55
The subsequent Christmas Special, “Last Christmas,” further explored a potential farewell through a dream sequence. The Doctor envisioned arriving late in Clara’s timeline, intending to reconnect with the Clara he knew, only to find himself in a distant future where she had aged significantly. This mirrored a poignant moment from Clara’s time with the Eleventh Doctor, where she cared for a frail, aged Doctor. Now, the Peter Capaldi Doctor was symbolically returning that care, witnessing Clara’s imagined final moments. This dream scenario presented another intensely poignant, almost cruel, ending for Clara. Fortunately, it remained a dream. Clara was still young, and their adventures were set to continue.
But what truly transpired behind the scenes? How did the pervasive rumors of Jenna Louise Coleman’s exit transform into her return for another season alongside Peter Capaldi? Steven Moffat, then showrunner, clarified the situation in an interview with the BBC, effectively confirming the initial rumors. He acknowledged that Jenna Louise Coleman was indeed intended to leave in “Death in Heaven,” and they even prepared two distinct endings for the Christmas special to accommodate her potential departure.
“That was her last episode. Then she asked me if she could be in [the] Christmas [episode]. So I said, ‘OK, I’ll write you out in Christmas.’ She came to the read through and did the ‘write out’ version – and again changed her mind. But the truth is I never wanted her to go. And with Last Christmas, I’d already written the alternative version where she stayed, and I preferred that version. Frankly, I didn’t want to lose her. She’s an amazing actress, and she never stops working to make Clara better. I was very happy to go the extra mile to make sure we could keep her.” – Steven Moffat, BBC Interview.
Of course, even the most beloved Doctor Who companions eventually depart. Speculation soon shifted to whether Clara might exit midway through the subsequent season. However, for that moment, Clara and the Doctor remained a team. Many viewers, including the author of the original article, expressed relief, finding the near-miss brutal endings of season 8 finales emotionally challenging.
The narrative surrounding Jenna Louise Coleman and her character Clara Oswald in Doctor Who is a testament to the character’s resonance and Coleman’s compelling portrayal. Her journey, marked by near-departures and ultimately extended tenure, highlights the dynamic and evolving nature of the Doctor-companion relationship, and the powerful impact of a beloved character on the long-running series.
