Like many devoted Whovians, after the 60th anniversary specials and David Tennant’s brief but brilliant return, I held onto a surge of optimism for the new era of Doctor Who. Series 14 promised a fresh start with Ncuti Gatwa as the Fifteenth Doctor, and while the initial episodes have been visually stunning and full of energy, a sense of disconnect has begun to creep in, leaving me questioning my long-term commitment to the show.
It’s a sentiment many long-time viewers may be experiencing. It’s not about outright dislike, but rather a growing indifference. The passionate spark that once ignited excitement for every new episode feels diminished, replaced by a sense of polite observation. This isn’t a reflection on the actors themselves; Ncuti Gatwa is undeniably charismatic, and Millie Gibson brings a vibrant energy as Ruby Sunday. The issue seems to lie deeper, in the overall direction and approach of the series.
The feeling is akin to a relationship that has gradually drifted apart. There’s a history of shared adventures and cherished moments, but somewhere along the way, the connection has weakened. Trying to recapture that initial magic feels forced, and the realization dawns that perhaps the show and its long-term fans are no longer in sync. This isn’t necessarily a negative evolution; shows evolve, and audiences’ tastes change. However, for those who have journeyed with the Doctor for decades, this shift can be jarring.
Perhaps Russell T Davies, returning as showrunner, and the influence of Disney are intentionally steering Doctor Who towards a younger demographic. If the goal is to cultivate a new generation of fans, then this approach might be successful. However, for those of us whose introduction to the Doctor came through Tom Baker’s iconic scarf and jelly babies, or who were captivated by the modern era Doctors like David Tennant and Matt Smith, the current iteration feels markedly different. Tennant, in particular, reminded us of the balance of wit, charm, and underlying pathos that defined the Doctor for so many. Smith, with his quirky energy and old-soul wisdom, also captured a unique essence of the Time Lord.
Alt text: David Tennant as the Tenth Doctor, a fan-favorite Doctor Who actor, smiles warmly at a convention, highlighting his enduring popularity within the Doctor Who fandom.
The IMDb ratings for Doctor Who Series 14 reflect a mixed reception, particularly amongst seasoned viewers. While new episodes are visually impressive and fast-paced, some of the nuanced storytelling and character development that characterized previous eras seem to be less prominent. This isn’t to say the current series lacks merit, but it may simply be catering to a different audience with different expectations.
For me, it may be time to gently conclude my dedicated viewership of Doctor Who. The fondness and appreciation for the show’s rich history will always remain. Occasional revisits to classic episodes or even dipping into new ones might still occur, but the deep commitment and emotional investment have waned. It’s a bittersweet parting, like saying farewell to an old friend who is embarking on a new path.
Alt text: Tom Baker as the Fourth Doctor, wearing his iconic long scarf and wide grin, representing the classic era of Doctor Who beloved by many long-time fans.
I hope the Doctor finds a new companion in the audience, one who embraces this new direction with enthusiasm. There’s no resentment, only a sense of acceptance that our journeys are diverging. The past adventures will always be cherished, and perhaps it’s time to revisit the adventures of Tom Baker and Jon Pertwee on streaming services, reminiscing about a different era of Doctor Who. Perhaps a quiet evening with classic Who is in order, maybe accompanied by the comforting presence of a pet – though perhaps not an eleventh cat just yet.
It’s a realization that sometimes the most cherished relationships evolve, and it’s okay to acknowledge when it’s time to move on, or simply shift the nature of that connection. All the best to Doctor Who in its future travels. And on a final, slightly possessive note, I think I’ll keep K9.
Alt text: K9 Mark I, the loyal robotic dog companion from classic Doctor Who, stands ready for adventure, symbolizing a beloved element of the show’s history that resonates with older fans.
