The timeline of Amy Pond’s pregnancy in Doctor Who is a subject of much fan speculation, especially when considering the dramatic events surrounding Melody Pond’s arrival. Pinpointing the exact moment for certain events is tricky, but we can make informed assumptions based on key episodes and plot points, particularly when exploring theories around a potential baby swap involving Amy Doctor Who.
One crucial starting point is the aftermath of the Pandorica events. We know Melody’s conception occurs in the TARDIS during Amy and Rory’s honeymoon, placing any pregnancy-related events firmly after this pivotal moment in Doctor Who history.
Furthermore, a significant amount of time must pass for The Church of the Papal Mainframe, and specifically Madame Kovarian, to become aware of Amy’s pregnancy and formulate their intricate plans. While Kovarian’s access to time travel adds complexity to this timeframe, the need for planning and preparation still necessitates a discernible gap in the Doctor Who timeline.
A key piece of evidence lies in the Doctor’s own knowledge, or lack thereof. In “The Impossible Astronaut,” the Doctor remains unaware of Amy’s pregnancy. It’s only towards the episode’s conclusion that Amy informs him of her suspicion. However, in “Day of the Moon,” set three months later, Amy declares she was mistaken. Crucially, the end of “Day of the Moon” presents the ambiguous “positive/negative” pregnancy test result, adding another layer to the mystery surrounding Amy Doctor Who’s pregnancy.
This sequence of events narrows down a prime window for a potential swap to occur: between “The Impossible Astronaut” and “Day of the Moon.” This period, when Amy is seemingly on the run and experiencing uncertainty about her pregnancy, presents numerous opportunities for a clandestine operation. It also aligns with Amy’s own belief that she is not pregnant in “Day of the Moon” – three months passing without noticeable physical changes could be convincingly misleading. The Doctor’s cryptic comment about Amy being “gone since America” in “Day of the Moon” further supports this timeline, hinting at a significant event occurring during their American adventure.
A second, less likely, window exists prior to “The Impossible Astronaut,” during the period when Amy and Rory are at home between their travels with the Doctor. This timeframe is less probable because the narrative suggests Amy is only just realizing she might be pregnant around or immediately before “The Impossible Astronaut,” with Rory being completely in the dark. This raises questions about how The Church could have acquired knowledge of the pregnancy so early in the Doctor Who timeline to facilitate a swap before these events.
In conclusion, while the precise timing remains open to interpretation, the most compelling and narratively consistent window for a potential baby swap involving Amy Doctor Who falls between “The Impossible Astronaut” and “Day of the Moon.” This period accounts for key plot points, character knowledge, and the necessary time for antagonists to act, making it the most plausible point in the Doctor Who timeline for such a significant event to transpire.
