As a physician navigating the complexities of modern medicine, engaging in conversations with seasoned colleagues is always enlightening. Their reflections on the dramatic evolution of healthcare over the decades paint a vivid picture of a bygone era. They recount times when medical treatments were groundbreaking innovations and when sharp clinical acumen was the cornerstone of diagnosis.
In those times, the family doctor held a central role, deeply familiar with their patients’ lives, conducting home visits, and providing continuous care within the hospital setting. Physicians of that generation spent their days primarily focused on patient care, unburdened by the digital labyrinths of inefficient computer systems or the overwhelming tide of bureaucratic procedures that physicians face today.
A recurring narrative from these experienced doctors centers on the significant shift in power dynamics within healthcare. They describe how physicians have gradually relinquished control to third-party entities and the burgeoning ranks of healthcare administrators. Stories abound of a time when doctors were unequivocally at the helm at every level of healthcare administration.
One anecdote from a general surgeon in Florida, recounting an event from 25 years prior, perfectly illustrates this point. Frustrated by a critical lapse in patient care, he stormed into the CEO’s office, emphatically placed the patient’s chart on the desk, and voiced his profound dissatisfaction. The CEO, after calming the surgeon, offered a sincere apology, assuring him that the issue would be promptly rectified. This surgeon felt empowered, perceiving hospital administration as a supportive structure dedicated to the well-being of doctors and their patients. Such a scenario, regrettably, feels almost unimaginable in today’s healthcare landscape.
While my personal experience is confined to the contemporary medical environment, even within my decade of clinical practice, the exponential growth in the number of healthcare administrators is undeniable. While most administrators I’ve encountered are personally affable, the pervasive administrative oversight of virtually every aspect of a physician’s work – from productivity metrics and efficiency targets (including patient length of stay) to admission statuses – gives one pause.
shutterstock_124488283
A diverse group of healthcare professionals in a modern hospital setting, symbolizing the complex hierarchy and teamwork within today’s medical field.
The critical question arises: who truly steers the direction of healthcare, and has the administrative tail begun to wag the clinical dog? I recall an incident from a previous position where a recently appointed, young administrator, fresh from academia, was brought in to manage metrics and handle administrative tasks for our group. Bestowed with a title like “administrative director,” he introduced himself to the nurses on the medical floors. Later, upon visiting the same floor, I was informed by several nurses that they had just met “my boss.” “Excuse me?” The implication was striking and revealed a concerning perception – that this individual was somehow in a position of authority over a team of over twenty seasoned physicians.
Many physicians firmly believe that their direct superiors should always be fellow physicians – individuals who comprehend the intense demands and realities of frontline medical practice, regardless of whether they also hold administrative roles. Not non-clinical personnel lacking a fundamental understanding of the complexities of patient care. Personally, I have been fortunate to primarily work under physician leadership, and for the most part, these leaders have been exceptionally supportive. Ultimately, I believe that our patients are our ultimate accountability, guiding our professional decisions and actions.
However, as healthcare systems consolidate and the proportion of employed physicians continues to rise, the question of professional autonomy becomes increasingly pertinent. In today’s evolving healthcare world, it’s essential for every doctor to reflect: “Doctor, who’s truly your boss?”
Suneel Dhand is an internal medicine physician and author of Thomas Jefferson: Lessons from a Secret Buddha and High Percentage Wellness Steps: Natural, Proven, Everyday Steps to Improve Your Health & Well-being. He blogs at his self-titled site, Suneel Dhand.
Image credit: Shutterstock.com
