David Tennant’s departure from Doctor Who was a moment of high drama, not just for the emotional farewell, but also because his successor, Matt Smith, almost immediately went against a vow the Tenth Doctor had recently made. Tennant’s tenure as the Tenth Doctor spanned three seasons and several specials before he regenerated in 2009, making way for Matt Smith to step into the iconic role. While the Eleventh Doctor, portrayed by Matt Smith, shared some traits with his previous incarnation, a natural consequence of the Doctor’s inherent personality, his approach to traveling in the TARDIS and companions differed significantly from the Tenth Doctor’s stance.
The nature of each Doctor’s regeneration has been a long-standing debate among Doctor Who enthusiasts since the classic era. Are they truly distinct individuals, or simply facets of the same Time Lord? This question remains open, but the swift contradiction of a firm statement made by the Tenth Doctor by his Eleventh self provides compelling evidence for the argument that each regeneration brings about a truly new persona. This contrast is particularly highlighted in the modern era of Doctor Who, continuing to fuel discussions among fans.
The Eleventh Doctor’s TARDIS Welcomes Amy Pond Shortly After the Tenth Doctor’s Declaration
Tenth Doctor’s Companion Ban After Donna Noble’s Exit
Following the heartbreaking exit of Donna Noble (Catherine Tate) at the end of Doctor Who Season 4, the Tenth Doctor embarked on a series of adventures, often with temporary companions. In the 2009 special “Planet of the Dead,” the Tenth Doctor explicitly refuses to allow Lady Christina de Souza (Michelle Ryan) to join him permanently in the TARDIS. He firmly states his reasoning, declaring he will no longer take on companions, a statement delivered with conviction. At the time, there was no reason to doubt his sincerity, and his actions aligned with his words – until his regeneration. Matt Smith’s Eleventh Doctor arrives, and one of his first actions is to invite Amy Pond, played by Karen Gillan, aboard the TARDIS.
“People have traveled with me and I’ve lost them. Lost them all. Never again.”
– The Tenth Doctor, “Planet of the Dead.”
This stark change in attitude could be interpreted in several ways. Perhaps the Doctor appeared indecisive, regretting his solitude after regeneration. Alternatively, it might seem reckless, as if the Eleventh Doctor disregarded the dangers of taking on companions after the Tenth Doctor’s painful experiences. However, the regeneration process in Doctor Who fundamentally alters the Time Lord, creating essentially a new individual who inherits the memories of their predecessors. Therefore, David Tennant’s Tenth Doctor did not break his promise; Matt Smith’s Eleventh Doctor simply operated under a different philosophy.
David Tennant’s Tenth Doctor’s Promise Remains Unbroken By His Fourteenth Incarnation
The Fourteenth Doctor Respects the Tenth Doctor’s Companion Stance
When David Tennant returned as the Fourteenth Doctor for the Doctor Who 60th-anniversary specials, there were subtle differences, yet he was undeniably the same Time Lord fans adored as the Tenth Doctor in 2005. Returning showrunner Russell T. Davies faced the delicate task of acknowledging the Tenth Doctor’s promise while bringing back Tennant. It was acceptable for Matt Smith’s Eleventh Doctor to diverge, but having Tennant’s own Doctors contradict each other would have diminished the impact of his original departure. Davies cleverly navigated this, ensuring the Fourteenth Doctor respected the promise made by his tenth incarnation 14 years prior.
Firstly, the Fourteenth Doctor did not seek out a new companion. Instead, he reunited with Donna Noble, a companion deeply rooted in his past as the Tenth Doctor. Furthermore, their journey in “Wild Blue Yonder” was unintentional, a consequence of unforeseen circumstances. The Fourteenth Doctor’s subconscious pull towards Donna, his closest friend from a past life, was driven by a need for respite, not a desire for new adventures across time and space. The Fourteenth Doctor’s actions were, in essence, the antithesis of his usual time-traveling escapades in the TARDIS. While Doctor Who has yet to reveal the Fourteenth Doctor’s current activities, it’s implied he remains in a state of peaceful domesticity with Donna.
Tenth Doctor with Captain Jack Harkness and Gwen Cooper from Torchwood
Related
Doctor Who Season 4’s Alternate Timeline Proves Torchwood Was As Important To Earth As The Doctor
Torchwood’s significance to the Doctor Who universe was highlighted in a compelling Doctor-lite episode during season 4.
